When Bobby Duffy was rising up in Essex, the query of what to observe on tv at Christmas was a straightforward one. His mother and father determined. “We had one telly — and also you watched it or not.”
His household was not alone. On Christmas Day 1977, upwards of 20m folks, greater than a 3rd of Britain’s inhabitants, watched BBC One within the night — The Mike Yarwood Christmas Present then The Morecambe and Smart Christmas Present.
The exertion and arguments of Christmas lunch have been anticipated to offer technique to the quiet hubbub of primetime comedy. Yarwood’s present had an deal with from (a spoof) Prince Charles, and a efficiency by (the actual) Paul McCartney. There was a hearsay that even the Queen delayed her personal dinner to observe it. In case you can look past the blacked-up Sammy Davis Jr impersonation, you should still see its attraction.
However the panorama has modified. In 1977, Britain had simply two broadcasters: the BBC and ITV. Then got here movies, Channel 4, satellite tv for pc tv, DVDs and, most momentously of all, streaming. Tv now not standardises a lot of the nation’s Christmas expertise. As late as 2001, 20.3m folks watched BBC One’s Solely Fools and Horses Christmas particular, through which Peckham merchants Del and Rodney misplaced their fortune. Final yr, essentially the most watched present was The Queen’s Christmas Message with 8.1m. No Christmas Day programme now reaches way more than 10 per cent of the inhabitants.
The nation doesn’t need to watch the identical factor, and nor do particular person households. They in all probability by no means did. “You do overlook that you just have been bored out of your thoughts watching The Two Ronnies or Morecambe and Smart,” says Duffy.
Streaming doesn’t simply give us alternative. It creates the expectation of one thing tailor-made for us. YouTubers and TikTokers are common with younger individuals who can relate to them, and baffling to older audiences who can’t. A latest report by the UK’s media regulator Ofcom quotes a 13-year-old referred to as Ben saying: “I don’t actually like watching the forms of exhibits which are on TV. As a result of a lot of the issues on Netflix are geared toward folks my age. And on TV it’s boring stuff just like the BBC and stuff for grown-ups and I don’t actually need to watch that.”
A 13-year-old Londoner referred to as Kame advised me that her household would rewatch Charlie and the Chocolate Household this Christmas, however in any other case she reserved the best to sit down it out: “I’ll go to my room and watch Netflix. Or I’ll sit in the identical room with my earphones in and watch one thing else.”
“My dad will normally persuade us to observe a movie collectively and we’ll reluctantly agree,” says Tom, a 16-year-old from Bathtub. “Final yr he bought us to observe all of the previous Muppet motion pictures from the ’80s — he simply needs everybody to observe his childhood.” Giorgia, additionally 16 and from London, says: “I can by no means think about us watching a Christmas film collectively. I keep in mind it was one thing my mum would make us do, however that sort of died. We simply stopped doing it, in all probability as a result of she wouldn’t let anybody else select.”
Right now Duffy is an instructional whose newest e-book, Generations, challenges the concept totally different generations have radically opposed political beliefs. However relating to TV, he’s struck by the variations: “As a dad or mum now you’re very conscious of looking for one thing that the kids need to watch. It’s actually onerous. I’ve bought a 13-year-old and a nine-year-old. We resort to watching previous episodes of Buddies on Netflix as a result of they gained’t sit by way of anything.” What would occur if he confirmed his youngsters Morecambe and Smart? “They might rise up and depart. They do this on a regular basis, with their iPad or telephone.”
It takes one thing really extraordinary for Britons to observe collectively: in March 2020, 27m folks watched Boris Johnson inform them to remain at dwelling; in July 2021, 31m watched England play within the last of the Euros. The identical traits are evident within the US, the place TV networks and cable channels alike are grappling with long-term declines in viewers numbers.
A lot of Era Z are youthful than the BBC iPlayer streaming service; they weren’t born when The Workplace Christmas Particular aired. They see the expertise of sitting across the household TV as earlier generations noticed carol singing across the piano: quaint and non-compulsory. They’re baffled by the attract of reside TV and the Radio Instances’s 292-page festive programme information. How will we discover issues to observe collectively this Christmas?
The arrival of tv modified Christmas. In his e-book Christmas: A Historical past, the author Mark Connelly stops the narrative within the Fifties, on the grounds that the Queen’s coronation marked the beginning of a televisual period. This new medium infiltrated Christmas like an undesirable intruder.
“A Christmas custom has been created with out it having something to do with Christmas in any way,” huffed Connelly. Tv, with its Hollywood movies and Coca-Cola adverts, had helped it change into “a global capitalist competition”.
Tv didn’t simply change into a part of the festive construction; it beamed out idealised representations of what Christmas must be. Charles Dickens had helped to revive the vacation with A Christmas Carol, whose jollier characters escape dancing on December 24. Movies equivalent to It’s a Fantastic Life, White Christmas and Dwelling Alone constructed our conception of a household Christmas. It’s a Fantastic Life turned “the Christmas Carol of the late Twentieth- and Twenty first-century vacation,” social historian Judith Flanders has argued.
For broadcasters, which at the moment are typically competing for edgy exhibits that may go viral (equivalent to Tiger King and Fleabag), Christmas presents a special problem. What’s going to collect an entire household in the lounge? What’s going to make these spending Christmas alone really feel as if they’re on a crowded couch? Animations equivalent to Julia Donaldson’s Stick Man, The Muppet Christmas Carol or Studio Ghibli’s anime titles would possibly maintain younger households; soaps equivalent to Coronation Road can carry collectively grandparents and youngsters.
All of Britain’s 5 most-watched Christmas Day programmes final yr have been on BBC One: The Queen’s Christmas Message (additionally proven on ITV), Name the Midwife, Blankety Clean, Strictly Come Dancing and The Wheel. “We completely exit to consider communal viewing,” says Charlotte Moore, the BBC’s chief content material officer. “That’s our function — to carry the nation collectively.”
“Tv is an invention that allows you to be entertained in your front room by folks you wouldn’t have in your house,” mentioned broadcaster David Frost. However Christmas TV prioritises these entertainers you’d invite to your house. There are people who tick the field: Apple TV Plus’s Ted Lasso, a few goofy American managing an English soccer group; the BBC comedy Ghosts; the sitcom Younger Sheldon; and Channel 5’s World’s Strongest Man, which takes place in California in June however is broadcast within the UK on Boxing Day. Nobody will be too discomforted by a music documentary like Disney Plus’s The Beatles: Get Again. Or you possibly can dial up the scariness (Physician Who, now on New Yr’s Day), the swearing (Taskmaster) or the teenage risqué issue (The Inbetweeners).
Streaming providers are usually much less invested in cross-generational attraction. They “are way more demographically targeted than generalists just like the BBC”, says Man Bisson, analysis director at Ampere Evaluation. “Amazon is focusing on folks within the 30-to-40 age group, Netflix is skewing very a lot to 20- to 30-year-olds.”
The expertise of realizing that different persons are watching can elevate a mean present — such because the BBC drama Bodyguard — to an unmissable one. Listening to different folks snicker makes you snicker more durable. However Christmas pushes you to share the viewing expertise with those that are bodily current, reasonably than these in your social networks. Which means the tv that has meant essentially the most to me this yr — HBO’s swearathon Succession; Michaela Coel’s sexual consent drama I Could Destroy You — is unsuitable. I did attempt giving a DVD of Succession to my mother and father earlier than final Christmas, on the idea it’s pretty Shakespearean, however I look forward to finding it this yr nonetheless in its wrapper.
Equally, I can’t see myself sitting by way of the BBC’s A Very British Scandal, concerning the affairs of the Duke and Duchess of Argyll, on Boxing Day with any blood kinfolk. I gained’t be suggesting we flip to Bridgerton, Netflix’s sex-strewn Christmas providing from final yr. However you by no means know: a colleague watched the beautifully specific Peep Present along with her teenage son (“the laughter manages to defy all embarrassment”).
TV is turning into ever extra fragmented, virtually like books. On Christmas Day, many households will discover a lowest frequent denominator. It might be a lot worse. Samuel Pepys wrote his diary when Christmas was nonetheless recovering from the Puritans. He appeared to spend Christmas Days listening to “boring” sermons. In 1662, he practised arithmetic. In 1665, he did his accounts. In 1668, he made a chorister “learn to me the Lifetime of Julius Caesar, and Des Cartes’ e-book of Musick — the latter of which I perceive not”. However all that’s little comfort to an adolescent sitting in entrance of Mrs Brown’s Boys, feeling there’s something extra entertaining on their telephone.
Christmas pulls us in subtly totally different instructions: attempting to be completely happy, and attempting to copy an idealised imaginative and prescient of what happiness appeared like.
This attachment to the romanticised previous explains why we proceed habits that, in themselves, nobody actually likes, equivalent to consuming dry turkey and Brussels sprouts. Step by step, some traditions are discarded — actually, what number of Christmas playing cards do you obtain now, in contrast with 10 years in the past? — however others reside on as a result of they join us to our previous.
Certainly, essentially the most enduring Christmas TV is common as a result of it was common. The Queen’s Christmas Message has been televised yearly in Britain since 1957, apart from 1969 when the monarch appeared to really feel she’d had sufficient publicity on account of a royal documentary. What precisely is the Queen’s message? How does it differ from the earlier yr’s? Who cares? What it lacks in scripting and performing, the deal with makes up for in familiarity. It’s a Fantastic Life was launched in 1946, however solely really thrived after an administrative error let its copyright expire in 1974. It was all the time nostalgic. The Nice Escape and Love Truly have established an identical attraction.
Dinner for One, a British sketch that’s pretty unknown in Britain, has change into established as a pillar of Christmas in Germany, Denmark, Sweden (the place it’s proven on New Yr’s Eve) and Norway (December 23). So many Norwegians complained when the present was as soon as moved from its standard slot that the nationwide broadcaster needed to air it once more. Like The Queen’s Christmas Message, Dinner for One has the advantage of being brief — 18 minutes.
But Christmas existed earlier than TV. One one that would in all probability not have put up with watching a BBC adaptation of A Christmas Carol was Dickens himself, who preferred to supply his personal leisure. On Boxing Day 1843, based on one visitor, he performed magican, concluding by producing “a plum pudding made out of uncooked flour, uncooked eggs — all of the uncooked standard components — boiled in a gentleman’s hat . . . in a single minute earlier than the eyes of the astonished youngsters and astonished grown folks!” On Christmas Day 1865, Dickens’ family danced till 2am. In Jane Austen’s novels, Christmas is an event crammed with video games too.
It’s attainable that, for a lot of households struggling to agree on one thing to observe, the reply doesn’t lie in scrolling by way of pages of Netflix suggestions. “We by no means watch any of the specials or fundamental channels on Christmas Day. We’ll in all probability play video video games and board video games collectively,” says Alex Bathtub, a 36-year-old with sons aged 5 and 7. “Maybe my age group is the primary to develop up with gaming being a very regular factor to do, and it feels fairly regular to play Mario Kart or Fifa with the children.”
When youngsters are underneath 10, it may be simpler for folks to share a sport — for instance, taking part in on the identical group — than to discover a present that they are going to watch collectively.
Video-game favourites embrace Overcooked, the place gamers attempt to make meals to order. John, a college provide instructor, began permitting his 10-year-old son to play Fortnite throughout lockdown. Fortnite’s gameplay isn’t too faraway from GoldenEye 007, which he and his spouse performed on Nintendo. His son “mentioned we should always all play collectively . . . it made him completely happy, so we did. It turned a brilliant level by way of lockdown and we’ve stored at it. And, hell sure, we’re taking part in over Christmas.”
Video games have the sort of attain amongst youngsters that tv as soon as had amongst adults: the makers of Roblox, a free sport with digital worlds, declare that half of US under-16s play it each week. In the course of the pandemic, Annie Taylor, who lives in Wales, began taking part in the sport along with her two grandsons in New Zealand. “They mentioned to me, ‘Granny, we might educate you. You possibly can play with us.’ It’s been completely implausible.” She hasn’t seen her grandsons, now 10 and 9, since 2019, however “the miles soften away whenever you spend 90 minutes taking part in Roblox”.
There are different alternate options to TV: jigsaws, walks, board video games, singing competitions and quizzes, additionally obtainable on sport consoles. The extra that deciding what to observe on TV turns into an lively alternative, the extra some households would possibly resolve they’d reasonably select one thing else fully.
But, as households, we do spend various time collectively. The hours that British moms spend with their youngsters underneath 13 has tripled since 1980; for fathers it has quadrupled (these figures are adjusted to account for elements together with the variety of youngsters). An identical development holds true throughout many western international locations, though not for some motive for French moms. Younger adults are spending extra years residing with their mother and father, due partly to rising housing prices.
In case your youngsters don’t need to watch TV with you this Christmas, console your self with the thought that you just’ve seen them loads already.
Henry Mance is the FT’s chief options author
Extra reporting by Miles Ellingham
Knowledge visualisation by Steven Bernard and Keith Fray
Extra from FT Weekend
Take our Quiz of the Yr
Which actor misplaced the area race? What NFT bought for $69m? Check your information of the occasions that formed the cultural panorama in 2021 with our 40 questions
The Artwork of dialog
On this unique piece of graphic non-fiction, Kristen Radtke appears look again at how people learnt to speak — and the way we’d do it higher within the pandemic age
Observe @ftweekend on Twitter to search out out about our newest tales first